HO-3 vs. HO-5 Homeowners Insurance Compared

The two forms insure your house the same way; the split is in how your belongings are covered and what a depreciated payout costs you.

By Tobias Lindqvist · Oct 06, 2026 · 7 min read

Featured image for "HO-3 vs. HO-5 Homeowners Insurance Compared"

HO-3 and HO-5 are both standard homeowners forms, and they treat the building itself identically. The difference sits in one place: personal property. An HO-3 covers your belongings only against perils named in the policy, while an HO-5 covers them against everything except what the policy excludes (Policygenius, undated). An HO-3 also pays for those belongings at depreciated actual cash value unless you buy an endorsement, where an HO-5 pays replacement cost by default (Insure.com, undated).

The price gap is usually modest and the payout gap usually is not. HO-5 policies typically cost 5% to 15% more than a comparable HO-3 (Insuranceopedia, undated), and the actual figures depend on your state, home age, dwelling limit and carrier.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Every premium figure below is an average estimate from published rate data; what you are quoted depends on your state, home age, dwelling limit, claims history and carrier.

DimensionHO-3HO-5
Typical annual premiumCountrywide average of $1,411 in 2023 per the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (Hippo, 2023); $3,503 average at a $250,000 dwelling limit in one rate-filing analysis (MoneyGeek, undated)$1,538 countrywide average in 2023 per the NAIC (Hippo, 2023) — typically 5% to 15% above an equivalent HO-3 (Insuranceopedia, undated)
Deductible structureOne per-claim dollar deductible you choose at purchase, applied to dwelling and personal property claims alike; the form letter does not change itIdentical per-claim deductible structure; moving from HO-3 to HO-5 changes the payout basis, not the deductible you selected
What triggers a personal property payoutThe loss must match one of the 16 perils named in the policy (Insuranceopedia, undated)Any loss not listed in the exclusions — including accidental damage and mysterious disappearance, which an HO-3 leaves out (MoneyGeek, undated)
How much personal property paysActual cash value, depreciated: a $1,000 laptop pays $400 (MoneyGeek, undated)Replacement cost by default: the same $1,000 laptop pays $1,000 (MoneyGeek, undated)
Dwelling and other structuresOpen perils — all causes except those excluded (Insure.com, undated)Open perils, on the same basis (Insure.com, undated)
Named exclusionsFlood, earthquake and mold are excluded (Insurance.com, undated); personal property losses outside the 16 named perils are denied under the named-peril clauseFlood, earthquake and mold are excluded on the same basis (Insurance.com, undated)
Upgrade pathReplacement cost for belongings can usually be added by endorsement for extra premium (Experian, undated)Replacement cost is built in, so no endorsement is needed for that purpose
Cancellation and nonrenewalSet by state law, not by the form. New York: after 60 days, cancellation only for nonpayment, fraud or increased hazard, with nonrenewal notice 45 to 60 days before expiration (NY Department of Financial Services, undated)Same statutory rules apply. Florida: 120 days' written notice before nonrenewal, 10 days for nonpayment (Florida Legislature, undated); California: 20 days' cancellation notice, 10 for nonpayment, 45 days for nonrenewal (California Department of Insurance, undated)

When Each Makes Sense

HO-5 fits a household whose belongings are new, portable and expensive to replace. Picture a two-earner couple in their thirties in a suburban house with a $300,000 dwelling limit and roughly $90,000 of contents on their inventory: two laptops, camera gear, a wedding ring and recently bought furniture. Their exposure is not the building — it is the gap between what things cost new and what a depreciation table says they are worth. If a kitchen fire destroys $15,000 of furniture and electronics, an actual cash value settlement under an HO-3 might come to only $8,000 to $10,000 (PennyPincher, undated), leaving $5,000 to $7,000 out of pocket. The HO-5 also responds to accidental damage and mysterious disappearance, which an HO-3's named-peril clause excludes from personal property (MoneyGeek, undated) — the dropped laptop and the ring that never turns up.

HO-3 fits a household whose contents are already old and whose budget is the binding constraint. Picture a retired couple in a paid-off rural home with a $200,000 dwelling limit and furniture bought fifteen years ago. Depreciation has already done its work, so the ACV-versus-replacement-cost gap on a sofa and a ten-year-old television is small in dollar terms. The dwelling, which is the large exposure, is covered open-peril on both forms anyway (Insure.com, undated). HO-3 is also the most common homeowners form in the U.S. according to the Insurance Information Institute (Coverage Classroom, undated), so it is the easier one to shop and compare. If this couple later replaces everything at once, a replacement-cost endorsement on the HO-3 is the cheaper first move to price (Experian, undated).

Cost Difference in Practice

Scenario: Dana, 44, owns a three-bedroom suburban home insured at a $250,000 dwelling limit with roughly $60,000 of contents, and chooses the same deductible under either form. The premiums below are national averages, not quotes — your number moves with state, home age, roof age, claims history and carrier.

Line itemHO-3HO-5
Average annual premium, NAIC 2023 (Hippo, 2023)$1,411$1,538
Annual difference—$1,538 − $1,411 = $127
Difference as a percentage—$127 ÷ $1,411 = about 9%, inside the 5%–15% range cited by Insuranceopedia (undated)
Alternative benchmark (Experian, undated, NAIC data)$1,569$1,649, a $80 gap, about 5%
Payout on a $15,000 kitchen-fire contents loss$8,000–$10,000 at actual cash value (PennyPincher, undated)Up to $15,000 at replacement cost (Insure.com, undated)
Shortfall Dana absorbs$5,000–$7,000$0 above the deductible

On these averages, the HO-5 costs $127 more a year. One depreciated contents claim of the size above costs $5,000 to $7,000 more — roughly 39 to 55 years of that premium difference. The arithmetic flips if your contents are old, few, or already depreciated to near nothing.

Mistakes Reader Make When Choosing HO-3 vs. HO-5

  • Comparing monthly premium and stopping there. The NAIC 2023 averages differ by about $11 a month ($1,538 versus $1,411, per Hippo). That number tells you nothing about the $5,000 to $7,000 depreciation shortfall on a $15,000 contents fire loss (PennyPincher, undated).
  • Buying HO-5 and skipping the endorsement quote. A replacement-cost endorsement added to an HO-3 can deliver the same personal property settlement basis (Experian, undated). If it costs less than the 5% to 15% HO-5 uplift (Insuranceopedia, undated) — on a $1,411 base, $71 to $212 a year — the endorsement is the cheaper route to the same $1,000 laptop payout.
  • Assuming HO-5's "all perils" means all losses. Flood, earthquake and mold are excluded under both forms (Insurance.com, undated). A flooded basement is denied on an HO-5 exactly as it is on an HO-3; that risk needs a separate flood policy, and the dollar exposure is the full cost of the damage.
  • Not inventorying contents before choosing. The named-peril clause in an HO-3 limits personal property to the 16 perils listed (Insuranceopedia, undated), so a dropped or vanished item pays nothing. If your inventory holds a $1,000 laptop, that is a $1,000 denial under HO-3 versus a $1,000 payment under HO-5 (MoneyGeek, undated).
  • Ignoring the nonrenewal notice window. Notices are mailed on fixed statutory clocks — 120 days in Florida, 10 days for nonpayment (Florida Legislature, undated); 45 days in California (California Department of Insurance, undated). Miss the envelope and you lose the re-shopping time, not just the policy.

Frequently asked questions

Does an HO-5 cover my house better than an HO-3?

No. Both cover the dwelling and other structures on an open-perils basis — all causes except those excluded (Insure.com, undated). The only difference is personal property: 16 named perils under HO-3 (Insuranceopedia, undated) versus all-but-excluded under HO-5.

Can I get replacement cost on belongings without switching to HO-5?

Usually yes. An HO-3 pays actual cash value by default, but most carriers let you add replacement cost for belongings by endorsement for extra premium (Experian, undated). That turns a $400 settlement on a $1,000 laptop into $1,000 (MoneyGeek, undated). Price the endorsement against the HO-5 uplift.

Is the 5% to 15% extra for HO-5 worth it?

It depends on your contents value. On NAIC 2023 averages the gap is $127 a year ($1,538 versus $1,411, per Hippo). One $15,000 contents fire loss settled at actual cash value can leave $5,000 to $7,000 unpaid (PennyPincher, undated).

Will an HO-5 pay for flood or mold damage my HO-3 denied?

No. Flood, earthquake and mold are excluded under both standard forms (Insurance.com, undated). The denial comes from a named exclusion, not from the HO-3's named-peril clause, so changing forms does not change the outcome. Flood needs a separate policy.

Sources

  1. Policygenius — HO-3 vs. HO-5 insurance policies: What's the difference?
  2. Insure.com — HO-3 vs. HO-5 insurance: Understanding the key differences

Written by

Tobias Lindqvist

Tobias tracks central banks, currencies, and the slow-moving forces behind interest rates. He's skeptical of easy narratives and prefers to follow the data where it leads. His writing often zooms out when everyone else zooms in.

More in Insurance

Featured image for "Understanding Actual Cash Value on Your Homeowners Policy"
Insurance

Understanding Actual Cash Value on Your Homeowners Policy

Actual cash value (ACV) is a way of settling a claim, not a separate coverage. It pays what the damaged property was worth the moment it was destroyed — replacement cost minus depreciation for age and wear — then subtracts your deductible. On a roof or a ten-year-old sofa, that gap can be most of the bill.

Priya Chandrasekaran · 9 min read

Featured image for "Term Life vs. Whole Life Insurance Compared"
Insurance

Term Life vs. Whole Life Insurance Compared

Term life and whole life both pay a beneficiary when you die. The difference is how long the promise lasts, what happens to your money while you are alive, and what you pay each month. Term insurance pays a death benefit only if the insured dies during the term and generally builds no cash value; permanent insurance such as whole life pairs the death benefit with a cash-value element (National Association of Insurance Commissioners, undated).

Priya Chandrasekaran · 8 min read

Featured image for "What Happens After You File a Car Insurance Claim"
Insurance

What Happens After You File a Car Insurance Claim

Filing is the easy part. What follows is a sequence of regulated steps: an acknowledgement, an investigation, a written acceptance or denial that must name the policy language it relies on, and a payment deadline. Each of those steps runs on a clock set by your state's insurance code, not by the adjuster's schedule.

Renata Ibarra · 8 min read

Featured image for "What Is Loss of Use Coverage and Do You Need It?"
Insurance

What Is Loss of Use Coverage and Do You Need It?

Loss of use coverage — printed on most policies as Coverage D or Additional Living Expenses (ALE) — is the part of a homeowners or renters policy that pays for a motel, a short-term rental and other added costs when a covered loss makes your home unfit to live in. It is a standard part of homeowners insurance (Farmers Insurance (citing Insurance Information Institute), undated), so for most people the question is not whether to add it but whether the built-in cap is big enough and lasts long enough.

Renata Ibarra · 9 min read