Traditional IRA vs. Roth IRA: Which Is Right for You

The tax break comes either now or later, and the paperwork that locks it in — conversions, deduction limits, five-year clocks — is easier to get right upfront.

By Tobias Lindqvist · Oct 06, 2026 · 9 min read

Featured image for "Traditional IRA vs. Roth IRA: Which Is Right for You"

A Traditional IRA and a Roth IRA hold the same investments and share the same annual dollar cap, but they tax you at opposite ends: one may cut your taxable income this year, the other never does. Which one fits turns on four specific things — your modified adjusted gross income, your filing status, whether you or your spouse is covered by a retirement plan at work, and whether you expect your taxable income in retirement to be higher or lower than it is now.

Most of the choice is reversible year to year. Two parts are not: a Roth conversion can no longer be undone, and the tax on that conversion lands in the year you do it.

Why This Decision Is Hard to Reverse

Picking the wrong one for a single year is a small problem. You can contribute to the other type next year, and if you over-contribute, the Internal Revenue Service lets you take a corrective distribution of the excess and its earnings without the 10% additional tax, as long as it happens on or before the due date of your return including extensions (Internal Revenue Service, 2025, for distributions beginning December 29, 2022).

The part that does not unwind is a Roth conversion. If you move $50,000 of pretax money from a Traditional IRA into a Roth IRA, you must include in gross income the amount you would have had to report had you not converted — normally in the year of the conversion (Internal Revenue Service, 2025). That $50,000 stacks on top of your wages for that year. It can push part of your income into a higher bracket, and the bill is due with that year's return, not spread over time.

And you cannot change your mind. There are no recharacterizations of Roth IRA conversions made in 2018 or later (Internal Revenue Service, 2025). Before 2018, people converted early in the year and reversed it if markets fell. That exit no longer exists.

There is a second trap on the way out. Withdrawing converted taxable dollars within five years while you are under age 59½ can trigger a 10% penalty on the taxable portion of that conversion, and the five-year period for each conversion starts on January 1 of the conversion year (Wealth Enhancement Group). On that $50,000 conversion, pulling the money at age 45 three years later would mean a $5,000 penalty — after you already paid income tax on the conversion.

The mechanics themselves are flexible: you can convert by a 60-day rollover, a trustee-to-trustee transfer, or by redesignating the Traditional IRA as a Roth IRA with the same trustee (Internal Revenue Service, 2025). It is the tax year and the clock that are fixed.

Side-by-Side

Every figure below is an Internal Revenue Service rule for the 2025 tax year, not something your brokerage sets. Your brokerage can impose its own account minimums; it cannot change these.

FeatureTraditional IRARoth IRA
Tax treatment of contributionsPretax if deductible: covered by a plan at work, full deduction at modified AGI of $79,000 or less filing single or head of household, partial above $79,000, none at $89,000 or more (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)Always after-tax: you can never deduct contributions to a Roth IRA (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)
Deduction when no workplace plan covers you or your spouseDeduct up to the lesser of $7,000 ($8,000 if age 50 or older) or 100% of compensation (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)No deduction exists, at any income (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)
Married filing jointly deduction/contribution rangeCovered at work: full deduction at $126,000 or less, partial above $126,000, none at $146,000 or more (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)Full contribution under $236,000, reduced from $236,000 to under $246,000, none at $246,000 or more (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)
Income cap on contributing at allNone — no upper limit on earnings (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)Single, head of household, or married filing separately and did not live with spouse: full under $150,000, reduced to under $165,000, none at $165,000 or more (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)
2025 annual contribution limit$7,000, or $8,000 if age 50 or older (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)$7,000, or $8,000 if age 50 or older — this is a combined cap across both IRA types (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)
Tax on withdrawalsDeducted pretax contributions and all earnings come out as ordinary incomeQualified distributions are not taxed; the Internal Revenue Service conditions include age 59½ and a five-year requirement, set out in Publication 590-B
Early-withdrawal consequence10% additional tax generally applies before age 59½, on top of ordinary income tax (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)10% penalty on the taxable portion of a conversion withdrawn within five years while under age 59½, with the clock starting January 1 of the conversion year (Wealth Enhancement Group)
Required minimum distributionsIf you reach age 72 after December 31, 2022, you may delay until April 1 of the year after you turn 73 (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)None for the original owner, at any age (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)
Age limit on contributingNone for tax years after 2019, even past age 70½ (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)None (Internal Revenue Service, 2025)

Who Should Choose Each

A Traditional IRA fits better if:

  • You file single or head of household, are covered by a retirement plan at work, and your 2025 modified AGI is $79,000 or less — the full pretax deduction is available, and it disappears entirely at $89,000 (Internal Revenue Service, 2025).
  • You file married filing jointly, are covered at work, and your 2025 modified AGI is $126,000 or less, for the same reason; the deduction is gone at $146,000 (Internal Revenue Service, 2025).
  • Neither you nor your spouse was covered by an employer retirement plan for any part of 2025 — you can deduct up to the lesser of $7,000 ($8,000 at age 50 or older) or 100% of your compensation, regardless of income (Internal Revenue Service, 2025).
  • Your 2025 modified AGI is $165,000 or more filing single, or $246,000 or more married filing jointly, so direct Roth contributions are barred and a Traditional IRA still accepts money — there is no upper earnings limit on contributing (Internal Revenue Service, 2025).
  • You are self-employed with income that swings year to year, and you want the deduction in the high years. Accept that required minimum distributions begin by April 1 of the year after you turn 73 (Internal Revenue Service, 2025).

A Roth IRA fits better if:

  • Your 2025 modified AGI is under $150,000 filing single, or under $236,000 married filing jointly, so you can contribute the full after-tax amount (Internal Revenue Service, 2025).
  • You are early in your career and in a low bracket now, and you expect your taxable income in retirement to be higher — the after-tax dollars you put in are never deducted, so the trade is paying tax now instead of later (Internal Revenue Service, 2025).
  • You are covered by a plan at work and your 2025 modified AGI is above the deduction cut-off ($89,000 single, $146,000 married filing jointly), which removes the Traditional IRA's main advantage while Roth contributions may still be allowed (Internal Revenue Service, 2025).
  • You are age 50 or older, plan to leave the money untouched past 73, and do not want forced withdrawals — as the original owner of a Roth IRA, you never have to take distributions (Internal Revenue Service, 2025).
  • You are the beneficiary of a 529 plan opened more than 15 years ago: a rollover to your Roth IRA is possible if requirements are met, capped at the annual IRA limit each year and $35,000 over your lifetime (Internal Revenue Service, 2025).

Frequently asked questions

What if I contribute to a Roth IRA in January and my income ends up over the limit?

It happens often with bonuses and self-employment income. The contribution becomes an excess contribution, but since December 29, 2022 the 10% additional tax does not apply to a corrective distribution of the excess and its allocable earnings, provided the corrective distribution is made on or before the due date of your return, including extensions (Internal Revenue Service, 2025). Next step: once you can estimate your 2025 modified AGI against the $150,000–$165,000 single range or $236,000–$246,000 joint range, call your IRA custodian and ask specifically for a "return of excess contribution," not a normal withdrawal.

I converted to a Roth last year and the tax bill was worse than I expected. Can I undo it?

No. There are no recharacterizations of Roth IRA conversions made in 2018 or later (Internal Revenue Service, 2025). The converted amount stays in income for the year of conversion (Internal Revenue Service, 2025). Next step: before December 31 of any year you are considering another conversion, run the added income against your projected bracket with a tax preparer, and consider converting a smaller amount across more years rather than one block.

What happens if I change jobs next year?

Your IRA is yours, not your employer's, so nothing moves. What can change is your Traditional IRA deduction: it depends on whether you are covered by a retirement plan at work, which shifts the 2025 single thresholds to a full deduction at $79,000 or less and none at $89,000 or more (Internal Revenue Service, 2025). Next step: check Box 13 of your W-2 — the "Retirement plan" box tells you whether the Internal Revenue Service treats you as covered for that year.

Can I just open both and split the money?

Yes, but the 2025 limit of $7,000 ($8,000 if you are age 50 or older) is a combined cap across all your IRAs, not per account (Internal Revenue Service, 2025). Splitting gives you some pretax and some after-tax money, which is a hedge if you cannot predict your retirement bracket. Next step: total every IRA deposit you have made for 2025 before adding more, and keep the record — the Internal Revenue Service treats the excess as yours to correct.

I'm 70 and still working part-time. Am I too old to start one?

No. For tax years after 2019 there is no age limit on opening and contributing to a Traditional IRA, even past age 70½, and there has never been one for a Roth IRA (Internal Revenue Service, 2025). You do need compensation. Next step: confirm your earned income for the year covers the amount you plan to contribute, and if you are weighing a Traditional IRA, note that required minimum distributions start by April 1 of the year after you turn 73 (Internal Revenue Service, 2025).

Sources

  1. Internal Revenue Service — Publication 590-A (2025), Contributions to Individual Retirement Arrangements (IRAs) (2025)
  2. Internal Revenue Service — Publication 590-B (2025), Distributions from Individual Retirement Arrangements (IRAs) (2025)

Written by

Tobias Lindqvist

Tobias tracks central banks, currencies, and the slow-moving forces behind interest rates. He's skeptical of easy narratives and prefers to follow the data where it leads. His writing often zooms out when everyone else zooms in.

More in Retirement & Investing

Featured image for "The Required Minimum Distribution Rule Retirees Need to Know"
Retirement & Investing

The Required Minimum Distribution Rule Retirees Need to Know

A required minimum distribution (RMD) is the amount the IRS makes you pull out of your pretax retirement savings each year once you hit a set age. For most people saving now, that age is 73 (Internal Revenue Service, 2024-12-10). Miss the withdrawal and the shortfall can face a 25% excise tax, cut to 10% if you fix it within two years (Internal Revenue Service, 2024-12-10).

Priya Chandrasekaran · 8 min read

Featured image for "Backdoor Roth vs. Mega Backdoor Roth: Which Strategy Fits Your Situation"
Retirement & Investing

Backdoor Roth vs. Mega Backdoor Roth: Which Strategy Fits Your Situation

Both strategies put after-tax dollars into a Roth account when your income is too high to contribute to a Roth IRA directly. The backdoor Roth runs through a traditional IRA you open yourself. The mega backdoor Roth runs through after-tax contributions inside your employer's 401(k), and only works if the plan document allows it.

Priya Chandrasekaran · 8 min read

Featured image for "Should You Choose a Roth 401(k) or a Traditional 401(k)"
Retirement & Investing

Should You Choose a Roth 401(k) or a Traditional 401(k)

A Roth 401(k) and a traditional 401(k) usually sit inside the same employer plan, share the same annual IRS deferral limit, and can hold the same investments. The difference is timing: Roth contributions are after-tax going in and can come out tax-free if you meet the rules, while traditional contributions are pretax going in and every dollar out is ordinary income.

Marisol Ferreira · 9 min read

Featured image for "The Inherited IRA 10-Year Rule, Explained"
Retirement & Investing

The Inherited IRA 10-Year Rule, Explained

If you inherited an IRA from someone who died after 2019, you are probably on a clock. The 10-year rule says the entire balance has to be out of the account by December 31 of the year containing the 10th anniversary of the owner's death (Internal Revenue Service, 2025). Whether you also owe a withdrawal in each of the nine years before that depends on when the owner died relative to their required beginning date and on what kind of beneficiary you are.

Renata Ibarra · 9 min read